Back with More Trouble from the Astors

Yes, yes, it's like ducks in a barrell, but the Astors have been so good to the world of estate planning and litigation that I feel almost duty-bound to report.

The N.Y. Times today had this article on the similarities between the recent fighting over Brooke Astor's will, and the fight nearly 50 years ago over her husband Vincent's will. Vincent Astor's half brother, John Jacob Astor VI, was left out of Vincent's will, so he contested it. John VI argued that Vincent was unduly influenced to change his will, which Vincent had done 26 times. Allegations of drunkenness, lack of mental capacity, and other sordid behavior flew freely. In the end, John VI, who was born to John Jacob Astor IV's second wife four months after he died in the Titanic, settled with Vincent's estate for $250,000. Vincent's estate was worth hundreds of millions of dollars, so the settlement was, really, "go away" money. In fact, Brooke Astor's long time attorney Louis Auchincloss claimed that the $250,000 was less than the cost of the attorney's fees if the matter had gone to trial.

Two-hundred fify thousand dollars in attorney's fees? In 1959!? The very rich are different from you and me.