Monday, September 22, 2008

Ambiguity in Charitable Gifts

A gift in a will setting up a charitable trust is valid, even if the gift does not specify any particular charity or class of charitable recipient. In Estate of Clementi, The Fourth District Court of Appeals upheld an Orange County Superior Court ruling that allowed the following language from a will:

"I give the balance of my assets to a charitable foundation or trust in my
name to be run by Richard Weisz. If Richard Weisz is not alive when I die, then I
appoint his son, Frank Weisz[,] to run my charitable foundation or trust."

The court held that the general policy in California is that charitable gifts are highly favored and that a charitable gift in a will must be liberally construed to uphold its validity.

While this policy is admirable, it can create problems for the trustee who then must administer the trust with no guidance as to how to direct the funds. This is yet another example of how an estate plan must be carefully drafted in order to make sure the wishes of the client are carried out. Sometimes a person may have a charitable intent, but has no real idea who to give their estate to. At those times, the estate planning attorney should ask a lot of questions to try to get an idea of what kinds of charitable organizations may fit with the client's charitable impulse. Are there any friends or loved ones with a medical condition that they would like to donate money to? Is there a specific group of people who the client would like to help (seniors, orphans, veterans).

A crucial part of estat planning is for the attorney to ask questions and listen carefully to the client. That is the key to drafting a plan that is clear to all involved.

1 comment:

krochetkids said...

A gift, in the law of property, is the voluntary transfer of property from one person (the donor or grantor) to another (the donee or grantee) without full valuable consideration.
charitable gifts